56 Comments
User's avatar
Robb Goes Places's avatar

Society is collapsing because the social contract is gone. Why care about others. Why helping, if this will give the poor a leg up and then they will eat you. We are ruled by narcissists and psychopaths, so better become unhinged like those or lose everything in the end like our stupid middle class. Be loud, unapologetic, dominant. Smear your enemies. Take what you want. Destroy Gaza. Become like the Jews and Godlike.

Expand full comment
pigz's avatar

Why I quit social media in 2026.

Expand full comment
Ajex Dugin's avatar

I am looking for a guru

Expand full comment
Tupak's avatar

Dr. P is the world's top dissident. Cheers!

Expand full comment
Sulaiman Achmed's avatar

Without American taxpayer subsidies especially regarding military aide……Germany will collapse

Expand full comment
Sabertooth's avatar

Dr. Pattberg is the new Prof. Heidegger

Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

Sein is ein Seiendes. Das Dasein.

Expand full comment
Everything Voluntary Jack's avatar

Thorsten and Frans and Jeff you are invited to our:

Free Friends Forum 40—J’ACCUSE Western Intellectuals Aka “Political Pilgrims” Exhibiting their Double Standards Moral Schizophrenia

You have NO Moral Integrity when you rightly and morally condemn the U.S. government’s Crimes Against Humanity then horribly and immorally aid and abet China’s CCP’s Crimes Against Humanity

Substack

https://responsiblyfree.substack.com/p/free-friends-forum-40jaccuse-western

You can tell us what you “Dissidents” will say when face to face with Sophie Luo about the imprisonment and torture of her husband, human rights lawyer, Ding Jiaxi still continuing in China?

Here is our Zoom and times, hope to see you—sorry for short notice

JOIN OUR FREE FRIENDS FORUM FOR A SPIRITED DISCUSSION

Saturday, April 19, 9PM (for South Pacific & Asia);

Sunday, April 20, 9AM (for U.S., S. America, Europe) —Note: New Zealand time

Jack Carney is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting.

Join Zoom Meeting

https://us06web.zoom.us/j/8245320024

Meeting ID: 824 532 0024

Passcode: 772388

New Zealand Time Converter

https://dateful.com/convert/new-zealand

Personal World Clock tinyurl.com/bdef97z7

Get free, stay free.

Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

Is this Oppression Olympics? 😆 THIS: https://youtu.be/buZhG_M4nOI

Expand full comment
Everything Voluntary Jack's avatar

Apparently, since you seem to like this word, you suffer not only from Double Standards Schizophrenic Morality but from Bipolarity too!

Well, done, Thorsten.

Maybe go see a ShaMman and go into that 5th Dimension of your projective mind and see what mysteries you can find?

When you come back from your Tranceendental mind, do have a good bad look at the miseries your democidal host CCP is bringing onto too many of its own in all too human, all too real, reality.

I hope you will join me in calling out the Crimes of the CCP along with those of the U.S. and Israel.

Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

Hold your horses, Jack. Watch it again. https://youtu.be/buZhG_M4nOI

Expand full comment
Everything Voluntary Jack's avatar

Join us tonight in ten minutes 9pm New Zealand time and tell me how free and uncensored CCP tyrannized China is, the Great Firewall and all. Then explain to me about 1928 political prisoners in HK alone. Waiting for you.

Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

We are a paid subscription.

Expand full comment
Everything Voluntary Jack's avatar

Thorsten and Hrvoje, please answer these questions for me, among many.

Neither of you mention any of the many Human Rights abuses of the CCP in your talk together and your published article by Frans that does nothing but praise the CCP as it seems you both do on Hrvoje’s program.

You two seem to believe the West censors more than the CCP does and you generally have greater political freedom in China than you do in the West, say Germany and the U.S., correct?

To my amazement if not amusement, it seems Hrvoje believes as you do—I had thought Hrvoje was at least a Libertarian. So you both are suffering from Double Standards Schizophrenic Morality and Bipolarity it seems.

Here is my recommended treatment for your mental illness:

Get on the social media and mass media in China if you can and tell the audience about the Crimes of Humanity the CCP has committed since 1949 and Mao through now to Xi. See if you can do that without being arrested.

You both do this in Western nations, right, you rightly go against the criminal governments with your talks and writings but neither of you have been thrown in jail for publishing or speaking what you want?

You can go to the links I gave you in that article I just posted on the article you posted by Frans

https://responsiblyfree.substack.com/p/free-friends-forum-40jaccuse-western

and add the huge amount of evidence I put here

https://responsiblyfree.substack.com/p/museum-of-crimes-against-humanity

And just start with those current 1,928 political prisoners in Hong Kong.

https://www.hkdc.us/political-prisoner-database

Do you agree with the CCP HK charges against the real “Dissident” Jimmy Lai that he was “colluding with foreign forces” and that he published “seditious material”? And that he should have been held in solitary confinement for nearly 5 years and should be found guilty and sentenced for the rest of his life to remain in prison in solitary confinement (which is considered by some to be torture after 15 days)?

It appears other HK dissidents were charged with "conspiracy to commit subversion" as was the Australian Gordon Ng who was sentenced to seven years in jail.

A Hong Kong man has been sentenced to 14 months in jail for wearing a T-shirt sporting the phrase "Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our times". He was also wearing a mask that read "FDNOL" - initials for another slogan, "Five demands, not one less".

So there is your “Free”, “Uncensored” East.

See you in 8 hours for my:

Free Friends Forum 40—J’ACCUSE Western Intellectuals Aka “Political Pilgrims” Exhibiting their Double Standards Moral Schizophrenia

You have NO Moral Integrity when you rightly and morally condemn the U.S. government’s Crimes Against Humanity then horribly and immorally aid and abet China’s CCP’s Crimes Against Humanity

You can make your case there as I will make mine, let the truth decide.

Jack Carney is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting.

Join Zoom Meeting

https://us06web.zoom.us/j/8245320024

Meeting ID: 824 532 0024

Passcode: 772388

New Zealand Time Converter

https://dateful.com/convert/new-zealand

Personal World Clock tinyurl.com/bdef97z7

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 19
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

Haha. Great sense of humor, Jack!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 19
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

Lol

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 19
Comment removed
Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

😆What is happening?! 🥹🙌🏼

Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

NEW If you never came across Dr. Pattberg's writings, well now here is a quick flick through The Human Farm https://youtu.be/buZhG_M4nOI

Expand full comment
Sheila Yang's avatar

Hi Dr. P! I got a copy of The Human Farm! The chapters on migration are priceless. Everyone is allowed in, but soon (maybe) no one will be allowed out! The lack of humanity is real. I’ve noticed that for quite some time. Its especially noticeable for humans who live alone. The country has become a prison of solitary confinement for the human race. Now writing on a review! Happy spring season! Sheila

Expand full comment
Tom Tokyo's avatar

We love Sheila Yang here!

Expand full comment
Soolstar's avatar

Corona tyranny woke me up. I don't forget anything now!!!!

Expand full comment
Katy Ka's avatar

Thank you, Dr. P. People don‘t know how we struggle every day, people don‘t know what we are going through.

Expand full comment
Marcel Proust's avatar

Great series, and very timely! When they said you will own nothing and be happy they meant it. This is in the UK as well. We are being crushed in our rights to free expression. Keep up the good work! Never give up on your freedoms! 👍

Expand full comment
Bumble Bees's avatar

Great work by Frans Vandenbosch, who lives in China and had the courage to share positive news about the Chinese miracle! And thanks for sharing, Dr. P! People in the West are trapped in shock, apathy, and distraction. China is more democratic than Germany or the UK—its genius and economic prowess know no bounds, except when confronted by the violent, militant West. I don’t know what it will take for Westerners to snap out of this stupor and start working with Asian nations to build a better world!

Expand full comment
exexpat's avatar

Can you add Brian Berletic (USA) living in Bangkok posting on his New Atlas channel https://rumble.com/c/TheNewAtlas

and Whitney Webb (USA) living in South America posting on her https://unlimitedhangout.com/ website.

Both of them incredible analysts with detailed references to it's sources.

There are a lot more people like them but mostly still in the digital, censored void.

Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

Absolutely, yes, we’ll be looking into this! Many thanks! T

Expand full comment
Fidel's avatar

Many "dissidents", even when sincere are products of intelligence and part of longer term agitprop operations.

All opposition is controlled opposition.

A is promoted. B is aggitated against B to hide C.

Expand full comment
Thorsten J. Pattberg, PhD's avatar

Well, the "dissidents" are all monitored—and yes, some of them become useful idiots. However, the very nature of a troublemaker is him making trouble, so I doubt he can be "controlled" by either party. Take Ai Weiwei, for example: the moment the Chinese artist and dissident reached European shores, he began calling out Europe's totalitarian speech laws. What I’m saying is, a true dissident is so shaped by his worldview that, as soon he is transplanted to another territory, he instinctively seeks out flaws and expose injustices. It never ends—unless he is shut down. Therefore, the true dissident cannot be controlled opposition. He is light.

Expand full comment
Fidel's avatar

Ah, they soviets did this too. They took their troublesome criminal and dissident Jews and shipped them to New Jersey. Soon western civilization was completely destroyed.

Expand full comment
Ani from Singapore's avatar

Wikipedia is used to trash-talk public figures and it is full of shady claims, half-truths, cherry-pickings, or outright lies to make anyone who doesn't agree with your ideology or politics look horrible. Anyone followed the wiki entries on Pepe Escobar, Stefan Molyneux, or Jared Taylor over the years? I wonder which government agency was paying for this! Disgrace!

Expand full comment
Dinotaur's avatar

Rainbow Europe is going full fascist I hear. That is good for the free world of China, Russia, India, SA, Iran, and Trump America. Don't know why the UK is implementing EU hate speech laws though. Didn't the British exit the EU before it was too late? No laws can fix the EU. Only wars can.

Expand full comment